BDSMforyou
Review

Mara's Final Exam – Just another erotic cliché novel in a BDSM jacket?

By Mrs Moriah6 min read
In this article
  1. What is Mara's Final Exam about?
  2. A high Harlequin-romance factor
  3. BDSM is so much more than sex
  4. Consent and responsibility
  5. And why did cocaine have to come into it as well?
  6. What image of BDSM does this keep alive?
  7. My verdict

“Mara's Final Exam – Just another erotic cliché novel in a BDSM jacket?“ was written for BDSMforyou.nl by Mistress Moriah.

I was recently approached by Eliot's House Publishing and asked whether I would be interested in reading and possibly reviewing the book Mara's Final Exam, written by B. D. Smartt, on BDSMforyou. In the accompanying email, the book was described as an erotic novella in which consent, dominance, discipline and limits take centre stage. That naturally piqued my interest, because these topics are closely related to what I deal with every day.

Mara's Final Exam – Just another erotic cliché novel in a BDSM jacket?

I received a digital review copy, with no obligation whatsoever to actually write anything about it. I appreciate that. However, anyone who follows me even a little knows that I usually share my opinion quite honestly. Even when it may not be quite what someone hopes to hear.

So let me get straight to the point. Mara's Final Exam did not win me over. For me, the story contains too many clichés and, above all, a number of missed opportunities. That does not mean, by the way, that someone else cannot enjoy it. Anyone who likes reading explicit erotic stories may well get on perfectly fine with this one.

What is Mara's Final Exam about?

Mara is a 23-year-old student who has set her sights on her fifty-year-old professor, Vale. He teaches psychology and deals with, among other things, addiction and self-control. Mara feels strongly attracted to him and spends the semester trying to lure him out of his professional role.

Eventually a meeting takes place outside the university, where the two end up in an environment in which BDSM plays an important part. They talk about limits, consent, safewords and the conditions under which they can explore their desires.

An older professor, a young student, an existing power dynamic and an encounter in which that power dynamic takes on a new meaning. As far as I'm concerned, that's enough ingredients for an interesting story.

A high Harlequin-romance factor

While reading, I was regularly reminded of the Bouquetreeks, the Dutch series of romance novels. The experienced, self-assured older man opposite the young, provocative woman who feels drawn to him. He is composed, she tries to challenge him. He has the upper hand, she longs for someone to finally rein her in.

It's a familiar recipe. There is nothing wrong with that in itself. Not every book has to be groundbreaking, and sometimes a predictable story is exactly what a reader needs. But I had hoped that the BDSM component would give the story an extra dimension.

However, the characters remain fairly superficial to me. Mara is sexually confident and used to using her attractiveness. Vale is the experienced man who knows how to impress her with his self-control and dominance.

BDSM is so much more than sex

In Mara's Final Exam, the BDSM dynamic revolves mainly around sexual attraction and physical intimacy. The dominant man takes the lead and the young woman discovers how exciting it can be to follow that lead.

However, anyone who truly delves into dominance and submission knows that the most intense experiences do not always have to be physical or sexual. Power can be felt in a look, a gesture or a single instruction. Surrender can confront someone with insecurities they barely suspected existed.

I would have loved to see that deeper meaning of power, trust and surrender in the story.

What I do want to give the author credit for is that attention is paid to consent and limits. Professor Vale discusses safewords, checks whether Mara still stands behind her choices and states what he does and does not accept. Those are positive elements.

At the same time, Vale is her professor. So a professional power dynamic already exists before BDSM even comes into play. Of course Mara is an adult and takes the initiative herself, but that does not make a lecturer's responsibility disappear.

Infidelity also plays a role in the story. That makes the situation morally more complicated, especially because within their BDSM encounter Vale is portrayed as someone who treats limits with great care. There is an interesting contradiction there. After all, consent goes further than agreeing on a safeword. It also has to do with the circumstances in which someone gives consent and the responsibility you bear towards the other person.

And why did cocaine have to come into it as well?

Another element I question is Mara's cocaine use.

Professor Vale sets a clear limit on this. He doesn't want any drug use during their encounter and makes that known. In the end, Mara has her sexual experiences without being under the influence. At the end of the story, she uses cocaine after all.

Perhaps the author wants to say something about her need for control, her habits or the limits of personal change. But in my opinion, that is not developed sufficiently.

What does it actually add?

What also bothers me is the association that is once again made between BDSM and drugs. Of course drug use also occurs within the BDSM world, just as in the rest of society. But it is absolutely not a given part of BDSM.

Precisely when people play with power, physical limits and psychological vulnerability, a clear mind is of great importance. Within many BDSM relationships and communities, high standards also apply when it comes to safety, responsibility and mutual respect.

As far as I'm concerned, a writer doesn't have to create exemplary characters. Fiction is allowed to chafe and touch on controversial subjects. But I do hope that such elements make a meaningful contribution to the story.

What image of BDSM does this keep alive?

I have spent years making BDSM more accessible. Explaining what dominance and submission can mean and how much responsibility, trust and respect are involved. In doing so, I regularly notice how many prejudices still exist.

For some outsiders, BDSM is purely about sex, powerful men, submissive women and boundary-crossing behaviour. That is an exceptionally one-sided picture.

Of course, a single erotic novella is not responsible for all the misunderstandings about BDSM. Nor does fiction have to be an educational handbook. But stories do contribute to how people see things.

When BDSM is once again linked to sexual dominance, a forbidden relationship, infidelity and drug use, without much psychological depth to counterbalance it, existing clichés easily remain standing.

While there are so many other stories to tell. About the special intimacy that can arise when two people get to know each other on a deeper level. Those are stories I would love to read.

My verdict

If you enjoy explicit erotic fiction, forbidden attraction and an experienced dominant man opposite a provocative young woman, you may well appreciate Mara's Final Exam.

The author also did not try to turn it into a romantic love story with a traditional happy ending. This was emphatically stated in the accompanying email as well. In that respect, the novella is clear about its intention.

For me personally, however, the story stayed too much on the surface. I had hoped for more psychological depth and a more interesting treatment of the BDSM dynamic. As far as I'm concerned, that is where the biggest missed opportunities lie.

I would like to thank B. D. Smartt and Eliot's House Publishing for providing the review copy and the freedom to assess the story independently. Although the book is not quite to my taste, I of course hope it finds its way to readers who do appreciate this genre.

Mistress Moriah

This review was written independently. I received a free digital review copy from Eliot's House Publishing. No conditions or obligations were attached to the review.

Dit artikel is ook beschikbaar in het Nederlands →